This is contrasted by the subjective view that is taken when describing the past. And we can easily imagine the same things happening to us.
It is impossible not to feel sorry for the soldier or the refugee.
The emotions of entrapment created by negation in Refugee Blues are reinforced by the line structure. However, it also introduces the experience of uncertainty of exile.
The slow continuous form represents the experiences of exile and isolation: Auden respectively, are both responses to exile and isolation and a cry for those who are suffering from them.
He notices the fish swimming freely in the water at the harbor and the birds flying wherever they want in the skies when he goes to the woods and marvels at them not having any politicians and wars as they were Refugee blues and disabled human beings.
Many journalists begin an article by introducing a real person in a real place and then discuss more general issues before coming back to the real person at the end of the article. He uses the absence of communication to demonstrate the entrapment which being disabled has brought upon the soldier.
It seems that it is their misfortune that they are still among the living, considering his dejected tone as he addresses his companion. An honest journalist will find a real person. There are, however, two important similarities — two rhetorical devices which you yourself can use to structure your own writing.
Simple analogies have been used such as that of the birds and fish flying and swimming freely and pets being treated better than the Jews have been used to convey the low position these rejected people, in terms that they understand.
However, this deteriorates by the end of the poem which concludes with feelings of hopelessness just like in Disabled. The whole poem is written as if it is a conversation or a description to a loved one.
The inhumanity with which Jews were treated during those times and the Holocaust and its terrible tales which few lived to tell are already well known today, but this poem highlights what these people must have felt, when they had no place to call home, nowhere to go and no one to turn to.
Both poets expose the reality of isolation and exile, showing these experiences to be entrapping, unjust and revealing emotions of hopelessness and powerlessness.
Owen also uses the constant comparisons between the past and present to demonstrate the injustice of isolation. In both poems the characters have bad luck and the poets clearly do not think that they deserved it.
However, ultimately, they have the same effect of illuminating the permeating entrapment that exile and isolation cause.
The form of the poem demonstrates how discrimination, and therefore isolation and exile, are engrained in society because of the ironic use of a form which originated from black slaves in a poem which is supposed to give a voice to those in isolation and exile.
He thinks that he heard the rumbling of an imminent storm, but it turned out to be Hitler sentencing them all to death. But he writes about a particular German in New York. The asterisks between the stanzas act like a mirror between the pre and post war, for example:Below is an essay on "Refugee Blues and Disabled Comparison (Almost Finished)" from Anti Essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples.
Poem Comparison Essay The subject of war and the loss of human life has had a deep influence on poetry in the first half of the twentieth century.
Oct 09, · Get YouTube without the ads. Working No thanks 1 month free. Find out why Close. Refugee Blues and Disabled, IGCSE Edexcel Anthology Poetry Analysis Melanie Kendry.
Refugee Blues written in is written as a blue, a sad song which strongly shows the melancholy feeling. We can see obviously as a refugee the couple has lost their home, their country and their identity. The poems “Disabled” by Wilfred Owens and “Refugee Blues” by WH Auden both address events that happened during war in Europe, collectively exploring the theme of discrimination, particularly the sense of exclusion and isolation initiated by War.
Poems “Disabled” and “Refugee Blues” employ slightly different structures.
“Disabled” is written in regular stanzas consisting of six to eight lines each. The stanzas are used by the poet to tell a narrative that takes time in past, present and future. "Disabled" / "Refugee Blues": A Poem Comparison Essay The subject of war and the loss of human life has had a deep influence on poetry of the first half of the 20th century.
Many poets from around the world had felt the direct impact of earth-shattering wars and went on to express their opinions through their works.Download